Compare Softcat vs CIL Management Consultants BETA

See how working at Softcat vs. CIL Management Consultants compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at Softcat vs. CIL Management Consultants. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.
Softcat company icon

Softcat

Employee Ratings

  • Softcat scored higher in 3 areas: Compensation & Benefits, Work-life balance and Positive Business Outlook.
  • CIL Management Consultants scored higher in 6 areas: Overall Rating, Career Opportunities, Senior Management, Culture & Values, CEO Approval and % Recommend to a friend.
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
4.2
(based on 232 reviews)
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
4.7
(based on 41 reviews)
CIL Management Consultants employees rated their Overall Rating 0.5 higher than Softcat employees rated theirs.
Career Opportunities
Career Opportunities
4.2
Career Opportunities
4.5
CIL Management Consultants employees rated their Career Opportunities 0.3 higher than Softcat employees rated theirs.
Compensation & Benefits
Compensation & Benefits
4.2
Compensation & Benefits
4.1
Work-life balance
Work-life balance
3.7
Work-life balance
3.5
Senior Management
Senior Management
4.1
Senior Management
4.6
CIL Management Consultants employees rated their Senior Management 0.5 higher than Softcat employees rated theirs.
Culture & Values
Culture & Values
4.3
Culture & Values
4.7
CIL Management Consultants employees rated their Culture & Values 0.4 higher than Softcat employees rated theirs.
CEO Approval
CEO Approval
Softcat Ceo Graeme Watt
98%
98%Graeme Watt
CEO Approval
CIL Management Consultants Ceo Giles Johnson
100%
100%Giles Johnson
% Recommend to a friend
% Recommend to a friend
82%
% Recommend to a friend
92%
CIL Management Consultants employees rated their % Recommend to a friend 10% higher than Softcat employees rated theirs.
Positive Business Outlook
Positive Business Outlook
84%
Softcat employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 11% higher than CIL Management Consultants employees rated theirs.
Positive Business Outlook
73%

Salaries

Salaries for similar jobs
There are no salaries matching this company.
There are no salaries matching this company.

What Employees Say

  • "Working environment" was the most mentioned Pro at Softcat.
  • "Long hours" was the most mentioned Con at Softcat.
Pros
Pros
"Working environment"(in 22 reviews)
"Hard work"(in 15 reviews)
There aren't enough reviews matching this company to generate pros and cons.
Cons
Cons
"Long hours"(in 17 reviews)
"Basic salary"(in 15 reviews)
Featured Review

Former Employee - Sales Support

I worked at Softcat full-time for more than 3 years

Pros

There are a lot of perks with working at Softcat, even being in admin, such as admin day, 4pm beers, nights out and team lunches but a lot of it is aimed around drinking and a lot of the bigger... company incentives are aimed at sales or the more popular admin people.

Cons

After over 3 years of working in admin for Softcat I wasn’t awarded the end of year bonus when I left, even though I worked the full financial year and up to the last week of the first quarter of the... next financial year, which was unbelievably disappointing when there was no decent enough reason for this in my eyes. I took this up with the CEO of the company and was just told that I wouldn’t be rewarded this as they would then have to give it to every other admin person who had left since the end of financial year, not the most inspiring chat. This unfortunately left me with a bad impression after 3 years of working with Softcat and many happy, fun memories there. I believe admin, across all areas, should have a higher base salary as I was only rewarded a £1,000 base salary increase after 3 promotions within the company in the same department. If I was in sales and was promoted even once, I would imagine the base salary increase is much more than £1,000.

Advice to Management

Listen to your admin employees and increase their base salaries.

Former Employee - Analyst

I worked at CIL Management Consultants full-time for less than a year

Pros

Ultimately, CIL is a very good place to start a career, with healthy exit opportunities. There is a culture of constant feedback, it is a great place to develop useful skills for a corporate career,... such as slide design, analytics (excel), and critical thinking / storytelling. Employees are generally pretty engaged in the subject matter, and there is a good culture of healthy debate. There is good exposure to private equity/M&A (great exposure for graduates, if that is what you are looking for). People are generally pretty friendly, I would describe people as curious and open. Employees really care about the quality of work. There are a lot of great people working at this firm. There are also good opportunities to involve yourself in any horizontal business functions (albeit time spent on this is on top of your project work). As the firm has grown quickly it had some problems ensuring that ops was up to speed. The firm made some new hires in ops recently so that seems to be in a good place now.

Cons

The working hours are long and unpredictable. You may be told on Monday that your last project, which you have been reading up on for a week, has been cancelled, and you will be joining a 'sprint'... project for the next 2 weeks (i.e. cancel all your plans and throw your reading in the bin). This is a consequence of the nature of the work. Salary is a little lower than at other consulting firms, which is seemingly justified by working less / having a good culture. Often, this 'trade-off' doesn't quite materialise, and you will find yourself at the mercy of investor timelines / whatever work the firm has managed to sell. TOIL (Time off in Lieu) is sold as a key mitigating factor, but this is discretionary and rarely materialises, and does not come close to compensating for hours worked (and if it does it never reflects the hours put in - you might work to 1am for 8 nights and get 1 day off, for example). The firm seems to have it's head in the sand about a few things: Employees and management sing laurels about the culture, and how nice everyone is. I would disagree - while there are a lot of lovely people, there is a bit of an 'old boys club' mentality (which I think management is aware of and is trying to change - there are some fantastic D&I efforts at the moment, mostly propelled by junior staff). You will be told that the firm is 'non-hierarchical' - this is not true. Senior staff can throw their weight around in the office (not all choose to, but some do) in ways that would get junior staff into a lot of trouble. There are some very cliquey circles (particularly around mid-senior management), that can make socialising with established employees difficult / uncomfortable for new joiners (I have heard this from several people). The environment is very gossipy; there are a lot of eyes in the office. The senior half of the firm is aware of all feedback/progress of all of the junior half of the firm. There can be a blame culture in review processes. The quality of middle management varies significantly (CIL had a void in this area not too long ago, so perhaps some promotions were rushed). There is little to no say as far as how you might specialise. Ultimately, if a project comes in when you are free, you will be staffed on it. The firm still seems to believe (or chooses to believe) that analysts have a choice - they don't. You will be told to network upwards to specialise - but this rarely translates into self-determinism. Often, you will be staffed on a project as you worked on a similar project previously. Most people who specialise do so out of happenstance. Some analysts find themselves doing several projects in one industry that they do not want to specialise in. There is a very low level of client interaction for juniors. A lot of the work is 'cookie cutter'. This doesn't necessarily mean that it's a bad learning experience, but a lot of the work is long and monotonous. You may spend a month cold calling, or tying up/proofing call transcripts. Currently, management's top priority is to deliver excellent client work. Employee well-being is a priority, but very much secondary.

Advice to Management

Prioritise employee well-being over the bottom line. Listen to your employees and their advice. Think about the company culture and how you can improve it (instead of blindly agreeing it is the... greatest culture you will find in any consulting firm).

Job Postings