WCIRB Reviews

3.3

44% would recommend to a friend

(48 total reviews)

Bill Mudge

65% approve of CEO

49% positive business outlook

WCIRB has an employee rating of 3.3 out of 5 stars, based on 48 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The WCIRB employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

48 reviews
1.0
26 Aug 2016

Mass exodus, lacking financial oversight, poor morale

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The good thing about this place was always the general staff and some of the long time managers. The hours are good. The office space is very nice, although way too extravagant for a nonprofit

Cons

Lack of organization focus Mass exodus of long time staff who know how to do things and new managers that are seemingly hand picked by the president and who share his lack of people skills Over 125 years of staff experience has quit or abruptly retired already in 2016. They see how bad things have become under Bill Mudge

avatar
WCIRB Response
9y
I am not one to normally post information on social media sights like this one, however, I fully support everyone’s right to have their say in whatever way they choose to do so. And, while we each are free to express our opinion about things, it is important to know the facts when assertions are made that are not accurate. So allow me to set the record straight on the facts of this specific posting: 1) The WCIRB – The Workers’ Compensation Rating Bureau of California is fortunate to have a great blend of new staff and tenured staff, all working together to fulfill the mission of this more than 100 year ‘young’ company that is integral to a healthy workers’ compensation system. There has been no “mass exodus” of long time staff – with a current staff of 191, the WCIRB has celebrated 6 retirements this year. Our 2016 retirees averaged over 27 years of great service to our company and we salute their dedication and commitment, as well as the best of enjoyment in their golden years. 2) With regard to turnover, other than the above retirements, our turnover rate in 2016 is 5%. We certainly don’t want to lose any of our talent, but in a competitive world, we all are able to make life and career choices. Again, on balance, our turnover can hardly be considered as bad as this writer has claimed. 3) On the budget, the WCIRB has no “$500,000 budget hole”. Our mid-year forecasting for the entire year indicated to us that we needed to tighten up certain spend categories in order to assure our budget for the full year. As in any business, it is important to be resilient to needs that arise during the year and adjust accordingly – that is smart management and our broad leadership team down to the department level continues to do so. 4) Lastly, to the assertion that there “is an effort to recruit employees to post only positive reviews…” that is just not true. Our staff members are free to state their views, if they choose to do so, and I most certainly welcome their views directly with me. If anyone has other questions about the WCIRB, our Mission, our culture or the opportunities to join us, please feel free to reach out to me directly, Bill Mudge, CEO, at bmudge@wcirb.com.
1.0
16 Mar 2017

Toxic culture

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

In heart of Oakland, good commute.

Cons

Tenured staff treat some newer staff poorly, with a clear lack of understanding of employees' functions supporting a company that deals with data. There seems to be some senior management tension, and it trickles down. Senior Management has favorites that get away with aggressive tactics and not collaborating well with others. Competition for few opportunities. General lack of trust. Seems to come from senior management. Middle management does a lot of work, management, administrative, hands-on, etc. Asked to jump through endless hoops with no acknowledgement. Many exhausted faces. Finger-pointing and blame makes employees risk-adverse always trying not to be blamed. Ideas for real improvements get shot down. More focus on low value work. Endless amount of manual admin work that could be automated. Retirement options (pension) slowly getting cut. The list goes on.

1.0
22 July 2015

A mixed bag

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The work-life balance is pretty good. You don't often work on the weekends. The benefits are not bad either. The office is located right at BART which is nice, but it is still Oakland which isn't as nice as the San Francisco location. Good for a career starter if you don't stay too long.

Cons

The company has potential to be a good place to work, but it lacks focus. There are strategic imperatives and road maps and core values, but they don't feel real. The various departments all seem to going in their own direction without much coordination or focus coming from the executives. There is way too much admin work that produces no value except to make the lawyers happy. There is a lot of burn out and people aren't engaged because they don't feel empowered (and are not empowered) to do things that matter.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 48 Reviews

Glassdoor has 49 WCIRB reviews submitted anonymously by WCIRB employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if WCIRB is right for you.