Birch Coffee Reviews

2.8

38% would recommend to a friend

(60 total reviews)

Jeremy Lyman

25% approve of CEO

39% positive business outlook

Birch Coffee has an employee rating of 2.8 out of 5 stars, based on 60 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The Birch Coffee employee rating is 24% below average for employers within the Restaurants and food service industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

60 reviews
2.0
4 Dec 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The pros were enough to keep me here for a few months but definitely not sustainable. My coworkers were amazing, the coffee is really good, the customers were great to get to know, and my CSL was understanding and great to work with. The tips are fairly good (this kept me there longer than I should have stayed).

Cons

Red flags from the very start. Training was a waste of 12 hours. We spent maybe 1 hour talking about coffee drinks, the rest of the time was the owner's opportunity to go on a power trip while he degrades and patronizes his future employees about the "right" way to take a customer's order. It was made clear to me that his ideal employee is a robot that will follow orders while giving absolutely no input or concerns in the process. At one point, a fellow trainee was even yelled at for trying to help another trainee through a hypothetical question while he chastised her for not immediately knowing the right size for Birch lattes. I decided to try out working the job in the actual store I would be at before quitting entirely (since the owner would not be there.) My schedule changed almost immediately from the hours the owner and I agreed upon in the interview. I was often being scheduled for 10-15 hours more than agreed upon and I was getting scheduled for anywhere from 30 minutes to 2 hours past the time I was available. It started to feel like the owner was disregarding my availability completely. That is, before I realized he was scheduling me like this on purpose. In one final effort to get the hours that I was promised at hire, the owner scheduled me for the worst possible hours to "teach me a lesson." The stories I have about him are unfortunately not unique to only me. I do not use this terminology lightly but as I do have educational training on the subject, I feel comfortable saying that the owner is undoubtedly the most clear example of a grandiose narcissist as I have ever seen. It is laughable that he preaches to his employees at training that they should try and have "empathy" towards customers, as I can say pretty confidently say that he doesn't know what that means. Disregarding the obviously concerning information above, the owner is also a less than ideal boss. He does the scheduling for all locations when he doesn't know how to make a cup of coffee much less know what it's like to work in any given store. He also makes no effort to work within his employees' availability. His expectations are unrealistic and if you can't meet him where he wants, you will be penalized. To him, applying at Birch is synonymous with handing over the keys to your mental health, time off, or having any autonomy in your work. I feel genuinely sorry for the CSL's that have to put up with him daily. The only way I would recommend this job to someone is if they don't care about having any time off, they can ignore petty workplace politics, and don't mind showing up to a shift only to realize the owner is in their store and will proceed to berate them for their entire day.

1.0
7 Aug 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The coffee is really good, and the best part of the job is the people you get to work with. It is the only saving grace you'll experience working for Birch. Also, the pay is actually pretty good for what it is. Your base pay is pretty good (or can be), but the tips really drive your paycheck upwards. I’ve found this job pays better than any other coffee shop. If they like you, and you work hard, there is a chance to learn a lot (at least there used to be).

Cons

This is the best place to work for anyone who loves a diminishing mental state. This job will be the best option to absolutely annihilate your mental health. They do not, and will not, care about you. But, the best part is, they will gaslight you into believing they do. They have a great habit of liking to play therapist if you are having a hard time, but god forbid you need to step away form work to deal with something - they will hold it against you. The expectations set are unrealistic and extremely high, and you will not meet them. No matter how hard you work, you will only be criticized for what you did not do. There are two owners, one who is empathetic and kind and the other who is a complete toxic narcissist. All they care about is turning over a profit, yet there continues to be only bad business decisions made. I beg you, no matter how badly you need a job, keep looking. The first six months of employment are strict and if you want to change any availability or have to take time off, you won't. The higher level managers will be your warden. The hours are awful, if you work you only work an 8 hour shift - which is really a 9 hour shift. And, the largest part of your job is cleaning. And they are hellbent on it. Your entire day is spent doing cleaning tasks, many of which are really only a monthly cleaning task at best. Anything not done is met with resistance. This environment is an iron-fist driven workspace. Diversity is almost at a 0. The few POC staff are treated worse than their white counterparts. Especially if they are managers. You will not have a work/life balance, only a work life. The sad thing is, before the pandemic, this company used to be such a great place to work. No longer the case.

1.0
6 Dec 2022

Avoid at All Costs

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The only pro in this job was that they desperately needed workers, so there were always shifts available.

Cons

Where to begin. I left this position three-four weeks after starting due to massive mismanagement on almost every conceivable level from training practices to base wage to how they implemented punishment for tardiness/lack of adherence to dress code. I've worked in coffee for the better part of ten years and have never had such a negative experience in a workplace before. The management team oversees every granular detail of employee performance, going as far as to take employees aside and instruct them on which words to edit out of their greetings (literally. I had a manager ask me to 'cut out saying 'the' after using a specific phrase) to customers in order to 'streamline' the checkout process. You can't make this stuff up folks. This hyper micro-managed atmosphere is made possible because one of the two owners, who is on the personnel side rather than the roasting side, is himself imposing these standards on not only the baristas but also the management team. He was known to come into various locations without saying a word to the employees, watch them from the corner while they served customers, leave without saying anything, and then report any supposedly poor performance to his team who would then contact you and dole out punishment. It was wild. They also started me, someone who's been trained in specialty coffee on both coasts, at $14/hr, which is at best disrespectful and at worst dehumanizing as NYC cost of living is so high. Another disturbingly noteworthy element is how Birch frames its customer service experience which also informs a lot of how they frame internal communication with employees. This is done using very specific verbiage, with the cups even being branded with the phrase 'Birch loves you.' The same language is used across employee communication, this idea that the company does x, y, or z because they 'love' their employees. This didn't sit well with me initially, and after I worked for them for a bit I realized that they used this language strategically as a manipulation device. My advice would be to avoid working with Birch in any capacity, no matter how good the prospect seems.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 60 Reviews

Glassdoor has 60 Birch Coffee reviews submitted anonymously by Birch Coffee employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Birch Coffee is right for you.