employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

America First Credit Union

Engaged employer

Listen to Your Employees - Teller America First Credit Union Employee Review

2.0
2 Sept 2020
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

You have potential to earn raises through level increases, and they promote from within. The people I worked with were nice. We pretty much had to learn to stick together because we were basically left to fend for ourselves when it came to having enough staff for our branch.

Cons

The starting pay is way too low. They say their pay is "competitive" and they care about providing for their employees needs and their families. Well, if that's true, increase their pay! If the majority of reviews say that the pay is too low, you should recognize it is a real issue and needs to be addressed. As a teller you are extremely undervalued. Your responsibilities are complex. They range from something as simple as a deposit, to dealing with fraudulent activity on accounts, which can be very stressful. There isn't enough support or training once you get out into the branches. In your first week of training they teach you that you will always have a supervisor or someone behind the teller line with you if you have questions or need help, but that is just flat out not true. When one teller started at my branch she was left completely on her own on her second day and barely even knew how to do a deposit. This put the responsibility onto the other tellers to help her since no one else could. The branches are always always always understaffed. This is partially because people keep quitting. When the branches need extra coverage for tellers, it is never provided. The whole time I worked there we never once received coverage for a teller, and rarely were able to get a loan officer to cover. The turnover was ridiculously high and we pretty much had a brand new staff by the time I left. The level increases also take a ridiculously long time to be processed and approved even after completing all of the trainings and tests. It takes months and months. The main complaint received from members is that we didn't have enough tellers, and yet we were unable to ever get teller coverage or hire more tellers. It genuinely seems like those who are in charge of setting wages and approving more branch staff are very out of touch with the actual needs of their branches and their employees. Very disappointing.

Explore other reviews about America First Credit Union

5.0
16 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great management, great benefits great way to learn the banking world

Cons

Saturday hours are no fun but it is a short day

3.0
14 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Part time is a bit more flexible in terms of scheduling. My branch manager is very kind and some of the coworkers I work with are also fairly nice. The training department is pretty cool too.

Cons

I joined this company with high expectations based on how the organization and culture were presented during training. Unfortunately, my experience has fallen far short of those expectations. I originally applied for positions that were closer to my home and offered more hours. I was informed that those positions had already been filled, so I accepted a role at the nearest available branch despite the lengthy commute and reduced hours. Shortly after accepting the position, I was contacted by another AFCU branch that was significantly closer to me and offered more hours. They wished to schedule an interview, and when I expressed interest in transferring to that location, I was informed that I would need to wait three months before becoming eligible for a transfer. What was not disclosed at the time was that even after reaching the three-month mark, any transfer would still require management approval. The lack of transparency regarding transfer policies was disappointing and should have been communicated clearly from the beginning. Additionally, the company appears to place little consideration on the burden of requiring employees, particularly part-time staff, to travel to training locations outside of their assigned branch. The first few weeks after training were relatively positive. However, once I transitioned into my regular duties, it became apparent that the culture at my branch was highly clique-oriented. Over time, I have felt increasingly isolated by several coworkers and one of the team leads. It has also been discouraging to feel as though asking for assistance is viewed as an inconvenience, especially when certain procedures were not thoroughly covered during training. As a neurodivergent employee, I sometimes require additional clarification or hands-on guidance when learning new procedures. I do not believe this is an unreasonable expectation, particularly in a role where accuracy is critical. Simply discussing a procedure once is not always sufficient training, and employees should be able to ask questions without feeling dismissed or burdensome. I have also experienced situations where additional precautions, oversight, or requirements appear to be placed on me when performing tasks that other employees complete without the same level of scrutiny. Whether intentional or not, this has created the perception that I am being held to a different standard than my peers and has made it more difficult to perform my job effectively. The cumulative impact of inadequate training, inconsistent support, workplace exclusion, and what feels like unequal treatment has taken a significant toll on my well-being and job satisfaction. I no longer believe my current branch is an environment where I can succeed or grow professionally. At this point, I see very little opportunity for improvement unless I am transferred to another branch. If that is not possible, I will likely have no choice but to seek employment elsewhere. While the company may be a good fit for some individuals, prospective employees should ensure they fully understand transfer policies, training expectations, and the culture of the specific branch where they will be working before accepting a position.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All