Pros
There really are no good reasons to work for Casey's. The operations level employees are great people, but you can make friends away from work. Those who stay are biding their time to retirement, in quiet desperation. Most of the newer employees who stay - stay because they are not looking at market rate salaries.
Cons
Cost of benefits is extremely high, employee contribution is 85% of premiums: medical, life, short term disability, long term disability, vision, dental, etc. Medical is high deductible: 5000, before insurance kicks in. Management decisions regarding annual review, raises (capped at 3% for top 20% of performance evaluations) are made based on liking or not liking the employee. Even if your manager gives you a solid annual performance review, his boss can override the review, and the same is true of your manager's boss - he can override your manager and VP approved review. I say "he" because all of the corporate decision makers are men - older, white, conservative men. Diversity is so low that they do not even attempt to tout it as a company goal, or initiative. I would doubt any claims of ethnic and/or racial diversity greater than 2.5%. There are quite a few women at Casey's: at HQ and in operations level positions. There is only one female executive: in the legal department. In general there is a significant lack of moral, ethical, or principled leadership. Many SEC reporting activities are borderline illegal.