Provide more PTO, Pay an actual living wage, Take care of your DMs and Management. - Store Lead Mud Bay Employee Review

2.0
2 Oct 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The health insurance is better than most. It’s the main reason I stay. Plus the community and daily fur babies we get to spend time with.

Cons

They say they pay a living wage but unfortunately this is not true. Maybe it looks that way on paper but it’s not the case. Wages need to be higher. Especially in inner city locations. They provide very little PTO (was is required by law + a hair more, barely) and your PTO is your sick pay and vacation pay in one. They also implement a strict attendance policy that uses up all your PTO if you are even 15 minutes late or have an emergency and need to leave early it counts towards your “points”. It’s the same type of point system attendance policy that is used at places like Walmart and Target. If muddies were provided enough pto to actually take a vacation in the same year they also got sick, positivity in the workplace would flourish highly. People are literally working themselves sick, using their PTO, and doing it all over again. It’s sad. The District Managers are worn out and stretched thin. A lot of them say one thing and do another. They are not connected to the employees in the stores and only connect with store managers. This creates a huge disconnect between ground level muddies and home office. If there were more DMs and they has less stores on their plates, this would provide for more quality time in each store and less manager/staff issues. There are huge discrepancies from one DM to another and things get promised and then tossed around so often that it’s completely discouraging for very promising muddies to attempt to move up. This results in a ton of outside hires in management. They’re not all bad, but a lot are inexperienced and use retaliation as their concept to deal with muddies that accidentally make them feel inadequate by knowing what they’re doing through experience.

avatar
Mud Bay Response
3y
Thank you for taking the time to provide feedback. We are happy to hear that you are pleased with our benefits package. The health of our Muddies is very important to us. In 2022, Mud Bay absorbed the cost of increasing health care premiums in order to keep the cost low for individual Muddies. Sadly, inflation has been tough on most families. We are currently evaluating our wages for 2023 and intend to roll-out our annual increases in January. We have recently revised our attendance policy. It has quite a bit of flexibility built into it. We encourage Muddies to connect with their district manager if they have questions or concerns. Additionally, we’ve recently added a few district manager positions to Mud Bay. We have reduced the number of stores each manager is responsible for in order to provide each of them a better opportunity for personal connection with Muddies. We take accusations of retaliation very seriously. We encourage all Muddies to reach out to the HR team at hr@mudbay.com if they feel like they are being harassed, intimidated, or retaliated against.

Explore other reviews about Mud Bay

5.0
4 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great company. Very friendly and professional. Treat you like a family.

Cons

Your work night shift. So if that’s not your thing you won’t like it.

3.0
10 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The employee discount is great, best benefit of the job in my opinion. You get 40% off all products. My immediate team and manager were absolutely wonderful and the work atmosphere was great. You get to pet cute animals every day and help people solve their pet-related problems. When I started, there was great training and education, but that has recently gone downhill.

Cons

Even though my team was awesome, you can be sent to other locations when there are call-outs, and not every store has a good manager and co-workers. It felt a bit hostile when I went to work at other locations. Upper management is a total joke. They are controlling and make decisions that impact store employees without consulting those who actually work in retail.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All