STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY - NO LEADERSHIP OR MANAGEMENT - Underwriter Nautilus Insurance Employee Review

1.0
8 Jan 2020
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Once was a great company. Knowledgeable CEO however he needs to retire.

Cons

Dis-functional senior leadership team that routinely throw people under the bus to get what they want or to discredit one of their counterparts. Underwriting leadership is terrible with the lack of direction and accountability. Morale is very poor and many people are leaving and not being replaced. There are several openings for underwriters, assistants and a manager and they can't find anyone who come to work for Nautilus. Pay is below market therefore you get what you pay for. RVPs are puppets and do what agents want. They do not back their underwriters.

Explore other reviews about Nautilus Insurance

5.0
1 Mar 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

No cons other than outdated technology and systems

Cons

Good company, training was good and consistent. Covered parking is a plus, they have many events that get you to engage and meet coworkers. Pay is good for the job title.

3.0
14 Mar 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Benefits, most co-workers are great. If on the right team it's great.

Cons

Lack of management communication. Lack of consistency.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All