I expected more - Designer Praytell Strategy Employee Review

2.0
1 Dec 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

There really are some wildly talented and genuinely kind people here. I've made a handful of friends/connections that I'm so grateful for.

Cons

Let's start with staffing—the number one issue across the agency. On the creative side, Praytell is bringing in more work than the team has capacity for. My colleagues and I *consistently* raised flags regarding how thin we were stretched, and each time we were met with the promise that they were searching for more talent—but this promise spanned 6 months with no new hires, and little effort to bring in freelance/contractor help. (Meanwhile, we were actively losing more full time creatives.) Additionally, our project manager went *above and beyond* to advocate for our time, but ultimately their efforts were dismissed by higher management. This leads me to the creative work. Because we were so desperately overstretched with creative production, there was little room for brainstorming, trial and error, experimentation, etc.—all things that are essential to good creative work. It was a constant churn and burn—always a game of catch up. Consequentially, there wasn't much opportunity for creative growth, especially for junior/mid-level designers. Praytell is skilled at winning cool/notable clients, but they consistently handed those projects off entirely to freelancers or director-level creatives, leaving the rest of us with repetitive retainer work. I understand the need for these accounts for business, but allocating your entire team to redundant monthly social content is a fast track to burnout and mediocre work. Additionally, because director-level creatives were so slammed with these projects, they rarely had time to invest in us as a team and help make our work better. When it comes to account management, Praytell has no backbone. Saying yes to every request that comes in from the client is not a sustainable business model. As a mid-level designer, it should not have fallen on me to say no to the client. Account management rarely stepped in to mediate or help figure out a path forward when client requests were unrealistic. This was the final straw for me. Diversity / Inclusion - Praytell means well. But it's not enough. It's a classic case of diversity at the bottom and white men at the top. I saw first-hand how my colleagues (who were neither white, nor men) persistently advocated for promotions/raises, only to be met with empty promises. Meanwhile, select men were promoted during a supposed "agency-wide promotion freeze". (One of whom has been repeatedly reported for misogynistic and racist comments/actions—another nail in the coffin for me.) The ERGs are a good resource for community within Praytell, but ultimately I did not feel they had any influence in the professional/business side of things. Benefits are good on the surface, but are difficult to use in practice. PTO (while unlimited) is difficult to use when teams are so thinly stretched. And the 4 day work week (a trial run during my time there) doesn't work when account management can't set clear boundaries with the client on behalf of their teams. *There is some top-notch talent at Praytell, and these words don't apply to everyone. (You know who you are.)*

Explore other reviews about Praytell Strategy

5.0
23 Nov 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Really loving the shift in leadership with Beth Cleveland as CEO and Katelyn Driscoll as President - it genuinely feels like the agency is in the strongest hands it’s ever had A wave of exciting new business, especially with major brands in sports, travel and lifestyle Some of my closest friendships have come from Praytell - the culture is genuinely uplifting, collaborative and empowering Senior leadership truly cares about people here and is invested in our growth, happiness and long-term success. I also really appreciate the transparency around company updates, finances, and the open dialogue that makes everyone feel included and informed. The agency is constantly evolving - from smarter ways of working to meaningful AI integration to expanding capabilities across the board Incredible new talent joining the team across all levels, and especially impressed by our amazing juniors who handle so much without ever missing a beat Love the ability to work remotely, while still having office access whenever I need a change of scenery Competitive salary and benefits, and our annual company offsite Camp Praytell is honestly the highlight of the entire year!!! Overall, I feel like there’s a real shift happening - a return to the scrappy, fun agency we started as, leaning back into our roots in the best way.

Cons

It’s hard work, no sugar coating it, and long hours can definitely come with the territory. Lately, there’s been a real push to respect business hours - encouraging schedule-send, being mindful of time zones and keeping weekends clear of emails whenever possible. It’s not perfect, and the nature of agency life means late nights still happen, but I genuinely appreciate the renewed effort to protect people’s time and create healthier boundaries. It’s great that we’re getting so much new business, but at times it does feel like we’re not scaling quickly enough from a resourcing perspective to staff clients properly. At my old agency everyone was on 8-10 accounts, and Praytell is nowhere near that. Most people average around 5-6, but when the work comes in fast, quality of work and team morale suffers. We also have a tendency to under-scope or mis-scope work, which puts added pressure on already stretched teams. I do appreciate the intention to cap people at 4 accounts to ensure there’s enough time to deliver quality work - though that isn’t always the reality, and I’d love to see us hold that standard more consistently as we continue to grow.

3.0
16 Apr 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Truly remote work Blue chip clients (They've gotten better with getting more recognizable clients to work with) If you're coming in as an intern or junior you will learn a lot and fast. If you're coming in at Director and above, I am sure it is better than your previous agencies. If you're in the middle, good luck.

Cons

BLOATED organization. It is extremely top heavy and these senior folks, who do not execute a majority of the work, receive the title and pay increases while mid and juniors workers are consistently shafted. Four day work week is no longer accurate. It is now "flex" Fridays which is also largely inaccurate depending on your teams. Unlimited PTO is also a scam as now they have a "suggestion" for what you can take. Either set a limit and pay me for time unused or make it truly unlimited.

2
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All