Penny wise and pound foolish - Anonymous employee Scholastic Employee Review

3.0
16 Jan 2016
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- The location (in SoHo) and facilities (rooftop cafeteria and "Red Bar" cafe) can't be beat. - Flexible work environment (casual dress, remote work, etc.), especially for those with children - Some really nice, smart people in the ranks - Creative environment - Opportunities to create products that make a difference in the lives of teachers and their students - Some good managers who recognize talent and hard work - Pay is decent

Cons

- A very high percentage of people are contractors. They work the same work week as full-time employees, but they're not given benefits (no paid vacation/sick/personal days, no health insurance, no 401K, etc.). These aren't short-term positions; Scholastic will just keep renewing contracts every few months for years. Because they dictate the hours, location, and direction of your work, not to mention provide equipment, I believe the IRS would say these people are W2 employees, not freelancers. (Kind of surprised Scholastic hasn't found itself in legal trouble yet.) - Many workers count having gone through K-12 public school and/or having a child in school as their experience in education. For being an educational company, very few people have extensive training in education (ed degrees, classroom teaching experience) or a deep interest in truly understanding the education landscape. - As a result of the above, some departments are well behind on trends in the education community. The products they generate are reactionary. And by the time those products are created and sold, the trend is on its way out. - Divisions are silos. Very little cross communication. And when there is, it's more bickering and competition than collaboration. - Semi-closed door environment. Many middle-level managers are constantly in meetings, and you only hear about changes/decisions second-hand or through gossip.

Explore other reviews about Scholastic

5.0
26 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

positive working environment, good people

Cons

great company to work for; no complaints

2.0
11 June 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Remote work and the clients are very nice to work with.

Cons

In my experience, the company's compensation practices lacked transparency and accountability. When employees asked questions about how their earnings, bonuses, or compensation were calculated, clear answers were often difficult to obtain. Decisions affecting employee pay were made without adequate explanation, and requests for clarification frequently went unresolved. What I found particularly concerning was the apparent disconnect between employee compensation outcomes and management compensation. Employees regularly experienced reduced bonuses or earnings, while management and executive leadership appeared largely unaffected by the same business decisions. This created the perception that the financial impact of those decisions was being borne primarily by employees rather than those making them. After repeatedly seeking explanations and receiving few meaningful answers, I lost confidence in the fairness and transparency of the compensation process.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All