Pinnacol Reviews

3.0

43% would recommend to a friend

(145 total reviews)
avatar

John O Donnell

50% approve of CEO

38% positive business outlook

Pinnacol has an employee rating of 3.0 out of 5 stars, based on 145 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The Pinnacol employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

145 reviews
1.0
1 Oct 2021

Rotting from top, down

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Remote work (for as long as they let us have it), the retirement plans, and the pockets of great leadership we have in middle management, and of course the people at the bottom are amazing human beings. I have many friends here I would give a kidney to if they needed one.

Cons

Pinnacol used to be a great place to work, but in my opinion it’s now become a hyper-political environment and a bastion of nepotism in a top heavy organization that has no viable solutions for the future. We lost our former VP of HR this summer who helped build our beautiful culture, but as the only VP with the courage to challenge our executive leadership when they wanted to impose their will on employees, once she left we feared the true nature of our executive leadership would appear, and it has, and it’s not been good so far. Our executive leadership has seemed completely lost since COVID started, and the virus has become their sole obsession, all while our market share continues to get swallowed up by our more technically gifted and nimble competitors. They now blame our “culture of niceness” for our market share losses, when in reality the cause has been a laundry list of strategic failures during their tenure, from their failure to update our core operating system and product tools, to our inability to successfully lobby the state legislature to change state statues which would allow us to privatize and sell work comp out of state. I’m also one of many employees who executive leadership thinks is stupid or “uneducated” for not being vaccinated yet, and I get to have the pleasure of watching them indirectly threaten us with a future mandate in weekly/monthly internal video messages and external articles they publish to stroke their own egos on their “heroic” vaccine stance. Having their threats hanging over our heads daily has been completely demoralizing for those of us who have given this company so much, and because we dare to control our own heath care. In the past, Pinnacol used to follow the data and what was good for the employee during times like these, but now we’ve become like every other heartless corporation or bloated state/city government that views its employees as “human capital” rather than actual people with feelings and free will. I plan on exiting the company once the vaccine becomes mandatory but it’s heartbreaking because I don’t want to leave, but if the company is willing to impose its will on me for what are clearly political and public relations reasons, then it won’t end there and it will only get worse moving forward.

2.0
23 Apr 2021

The dream of the 90s

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

* Benefits are decent * Pay is good when the quarterly bonus is good (not so much lately) * lots of downtime if you like a slower pace * People are generally friendly

Cons

At the time of writing this, Glassdoor says the company is going through a "hiring surge". You might think it's because the company has a new project or is experiencing stellar growth and you'd be wrong. It's because product owners, designers, and engineers have been fleeing the company in droves over the past six months. This is an old company that's convinced itself it's a tech company. They know some of the agile jargon, they even have the agile ceremonies, and they talk up being "product-led", but it's all fluff. After a briefly being nominally "product-led", the product leadership was fired and replaced by lean coaches and project managers. Understand that this is a waterfall shop with fancier names. Tech works for sales and underwriting. This was made regularly clear by the fact that any time there was a disagreement between tech and the business side on absolutely anything, no matter how sound the tech reasoning was or how minor the disagreement was, tech lost. It doesn't matter if the disagreement was about what to build and how to do it, or a process internal to the tech teams, or even tools that only tech uses. If business didn't like it or see the value in it, it was gone. One notable quote from the CIO after sales was ruffled over the product team working with their agency clients for user testing: "From now on all products need to be 90% complete before a user sees it. We don't need to user test because we know what our users want". Now, I'm guessing that a Pinnacol rep will reply to this talking about how they're in the process of going through a "digital transformation". I'm not taking a jab at you, Senior Communications Specialist. You're doing your job and everyone I knew at PA who did your job was very kind. This "transformation" has been going on for at least a decade only to fail and be restarted repeatedly over that time. So far every product produced during these transformations has been abandoned and/or rebooted from scratch. This happened several times while I was here. For all I know, the current do over of the transformation is still ongoing and the products I worked on are still being built. However, out of the 30+ product owners, engineers, QAs, DevOps, and designers who were working on this transformation iteration for the past couple years, only one is still around. Does this mean you shouldn't work here? Maybe. A tech job can be very good if you don't want to do much. I knew coworkers who put a lot of hours into other projects while on the clock. I knew people who could be mistaken for being retired. It's pretty easy to slip by doing nothing if you like that sort of thing. If you want to learn and build things beyond MVPs, this probably isn't the place for you anymore.

avatar
Pinnacol Response
5y
As the CIO at Pinnacol, I want to validate the reviews posted here in the last week or so. I acknowledge the frustration and respect the decision of many of my very talented tech employees who chose to leave the organization this year. Agile transformations and product led transformations are challenging, and in the process of becoming something different and better, there will be failures and it will often feel frustrating and painful. I will be the first to say that there are many things we have done well and there are many things that we have failed at. It’s what we do with our failures that matter. Pinnacol is committed now more than ever to realize our vision of becoming a product led, agile organization. While I understand that prior employees left because they did not see a path forward to realizing this reality, within the past two months we have renewed the commitment from all levels and organizations of Pinnacol to becoming a product led, agile company. We are making investments in our teams, leadership and company practices to move us forward. I believe we will still face challenges but I am very proud of Pinnacol for choosing to lean into the challenges of “becoming” instead of staying in the status quo.
1.0
13 July 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great pay and benefits, good work/life balance

Cons

The IS Department is very dysfunctional and averse to change. I was actually reprimanded for suggesting that we implement code review. They also lack technical leadership within the management ranks and don't seem to prioritize other tech industry standards such as knowledge redundancy and documentation. Their excuse for this is always "we're not a tech company - we're an insurance company". I did get the impression that other departments were better. The CEO seems to have a good vision but he is reckless with feedback that he requests of the employees. For example, I went to their quarterly new hire employee breakfast and was asked to provide feedback about my experience at Pinnacol so far. I explained some of the issues we were facing on my team and a few days later found myself in trouble with my boss. If he is going to ask for feedback, he should be more careful with how this information is handled so that employees feel comfortable coming forward without fear of retribution.

avatar
Pinnacol Response
8y
It is an exciting time to be in the Pinnacol IT organization. While it’s true we are an insurance company, IT trends show insurance is exactly where you want to be. We are working on world class customer portals, Data Science analytics, Salesforce solutions and core system modernization all with the lens of going digital. And while the technology is fun, the people who work here are our greatest asset. They are the heart behind everything we produce for our internal and external customers. We have great passion for our work as we care about each other and we know it ultimately serves our community. There is a reason why Pinnacol was voted, by its employees, as one of the best places to work in Denver. We are saddened that your experience with Pinnacol did not reflect a positive outcome. Your observations will give us the opportunity to improve current and future employee experiences. We wish you well in your future endeavors.
Viewing 1 - 3 of 145 Reviews

Glassdoor has 153 Pinnacol reviews submitted anonymously by Pinnacol employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Pinnacol is right for you.