Horrible Management... Wonder this Company is successful... - PIP Examiner/TA-1 GEICO Employee Review

1.0
5 June 2013
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great people outside of management.

Cons

A word to the wise... the positive comments being posted on here are by employees of the company being paid to do so. And FYI to those individuals, I have already found new employment and am very happy with my new company. And yes, it is in the same industry. I came into this company thinking I want this to be the last company I work for. After a year of employment I knew this wasn't possible I have 5 years experience in the insurance industry. After relocating to New York I looked into working at GEICO. When you go to an interview at GEICO you are herded through like cattle. If you make it through the first step of the process you are then granted an interview with a supervisor and then a manager. If you qualify they will hire you on the spot. Which can be a good thing but after further scrutiny the reason they hire the way they do is because of such high turnover (of the 16 people in training there are only 9 people left working there, they all left on their own accord). You then begin the training process which is 6 months long for each department. Well, training is about 8 weeks in each department but then you go to "transition". Transition is a glorified version of babysitting in which your "coach" watches every move you make and orders you to perform tasks like a drill sergeant. One of the huge problems with this company is some of their programs. This is the main reason I left the company. The Supervisor Leadership Program (SLP) puts individuals that are proven leaders (had decent grades in college) through all levels of claims within 2 years. They put these individuals with absolutely no claims experience in charge of individuals with 3 + years of claims experience to coach them to succeed. Which is difficult to understand when these individuals are already succeeding. They then proceed to give these individuals preferential treatment in regards to promotions up to and including management positions. Now you have individuals who have never performed the job that they are managing. For any individual who has ever worked in corporate America, this is the antithesis of what a successful company should do. I am very happy and completely satisfied with my career choice and the position in which I am now working. This was meant to give potential employees an idea of what to expect if they accept a position at GEICO in Woodbury, NY. There is much more to say but I don't have the time to go through it. Thank you.

Explore other reviews about GEICO

5.0
8 June 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

GEICO is one of the largest employers in my smaller town, so I've heard all the good, the bad, and the ugly. What a pleasant surprise it's been working here! There is so much intentional change to create a great employee experience and get the right team leaders in place. Highly recommend not putting too much weight into older negative comments if you're thinking about applying. I've been very happy with my salary, the benefits/time off, culture, and leadership (both locally and senior leaders). I feel like there's a lot of room to continue to grow my career here and I see the same opportunities for others.

Cons

Really nothing major that I can think of!

2.0
26 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Interesting problems to work on. Good benefits. Decent pay.

Cons

Managers will gaslight you and upper leadership is constantly changing, so expect projects you're working on to be thrown out every 6 months. Many people burn out and quit after some time and are never back filled, so you'll be expected to take on their workload. Some of my colleagues were working 80 hour work weeks to keep up with the work load and yet told they were not performing well enough. There also wasn't much diversity.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All