Churn and Burn | Slave Ship Adventure Ride | Dystopian Toxic Corporate Culture | Sales Company Masquerading as an Agency - Brand Manager My Amazon Guy Employee Review

1.0
18 July 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

-Great learning opportunity and lots of good people at the company, who sadly won't work at the company for long, as almost no one does. Time flows differently at MAG. What people in other companies learn in 3 months, you are going to learn in a month. It's almost like in those movies when you are close to the black hole the time just flows differently for you. In this case it's nothing to do with black holes, rather it's extreme pressure and lots of overtime. - They have a good system and lots of processes. When it works, it's beautiful, but when it doesn't work it's an absolute dumpster fire.

Cons

Steven Pope likes to say that they are an education company that happens to be an agency. Instead, they are a sales company masquerading as an agency. I would give it 2 stars, but I am going for 1/5 to balance things out, as I know how hard the company works at removing anything negative about them online. So about the cons - Dystopian levels of toxicity in the workplace. Every single smile in the company is fake and you have to be very gullible not to notice that. Everyone wears a mask. Pretending that they are enjoying themselves, while they can't wait to move on. It's such a stereotypical toxic corporate environment that it's downright comical at times. Some people join and in the first month they ignore the red flags and think that they found an employment heaven. 2 months later they are broken and end up crying. None of this is surprising of course, as everyone including the top management is afraid to speak their mind because they know they can get deleted over night. - They will expect you to work overtime without saying it. Then they will tell you that you shouldn't work too much overtime, but what they really mean is don't track too much time. Truth is, they pressure you into working without time tracking, so that new arrivals aren't freaked out by the time tracking stats. But make no mistake, you will be expected to work more than the agreed hours constantly. You can easily confirm this by checking the calendar and activity levels of other employees at your position. - There is no candor at all at the company. They will lie to you, or delete you overnight if you are seen as a "troublemaker". The troublemaker is anyone who has anything to say about some of the horrible practices at the company. I've seen more than 15 people in managerial positions fired overnight, without ever getting the chance to explain their position or say goodbye to their former colleagues. - The clients are routinely lied to by the sales, after which a BM has to deal with that client and set expectations all over again. To make things worse, someone will delete the problematic correspondence with the client, so you complaining about it will make it seem like you are a problem. Take screenshots, record everything, act quickly, but don't expect too much. Only the veteran senior managers have the guts to stick up for their employees, but those are a rare breed, and you won't find too many at MAG. This is also by design I imagine. -Once they decide to fire you, they give you a Performance Improvement Plan, or a "PIP", which serves 2 purposes. 1. It is meant to push the narrative that you are being fired for your performance, even though they might have other reasons for it and you were praised for your performance up until recently. 2. It is also used as proof that people who perform badly are given a chance, but the company has data that shows that this never works. They do their best to make those 2 weeks miserable for you, and if you try to use their "open door policy" and reach out to the top guy, they will fire you on spot and break the 2 week PIP rule. Everything to shut you up. Do I suggest working at MAG? Actually I do, but only if you are new to Amazon and not looking for a long term employment opportunity. You will learn a ton, and after a few months working at MAG all of your other jobs will look enjoyable and easy in comparison. Just don't expect to change anything, and don't give them ideas how to make lives for future employees more miserable. You are only there temporarily, so don't share too much of your knowledge right away. The HR and the open door policy are not there to help you, they exist to have you report on yourself and give them an idea of when to fire you. Don't try to fix things. The things you see as broken are by design. Toxicity is not a bug, it's a feature.

avatar
My Amazon Guy Response
1y
Thank you for taking the time to share your detailed feedback. We appreciate your acknowledgment of the learning opportunities and efficient processes at MAG when they work well. We're concerned by your description of the work environment and culture. While we strive for high performance, we don't condone practices that lead to burnout or a toxic atmosphere. Your comments about overtime expectations, communication issues, and the handling of performance improvement plans are particularly troubling. We take allegations of misrepresentation to clients very seriously. If you have specific instances where this occurred, we encourage you to report them through our ethics hotline for investigation. Regarding terminations, we aim to handle these with professionalism and respect. If you witnessed abrupt dismissals without due process, this doesn't align with our intended practices. Your advice to take screenshots and record everything suggests a deep mistrust that we need to address. Our open door policy is meant to foster genuine communication, not to gather information for terminations. We're committed to continuous improvement and will use your feedback to review our practices, especially around work-life balance, transparency, and employee support. We've initiated an internal review of our culture and management practices based on comments like yours. To current and future employees: we hear these concerns and are actively working to create a more positive, supportive environment. We encourage open dialogue and welcome constructive feedback to help us improve. Thank you again for your candid review. We wish you the best in your future endeavors. -Steven Pope

Explore other reviews about My Amazon Guy

5.0
29 Sept 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great company: supportive team, good pay, clear growth, and respectful culture. Outstanding experience overall—no complaints, just gratitude.

Cons

No real complaints, more pros than cons.

2
avatar
My Amazon Guy Response
9mo
We're really glad to hear that you’ve felt supported, respected, and have seen growth here at My Amazon Guy. That’s exactly the kind of culture we’re working hard to build every day. We know no company is perfect, but hearing feedback like this tells us we’re on the right track. We appreciate you being part of the team and contributing to that growth.
1.0
26 Jan 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Remote work - that’s all no night differential pay

Cons

They will screencapture everything on your screen and will force you to brand yourself and your personal account with their brand. Extremely invasive.

avatar
My Amazon Guy Response
4mo
Thank you for sharing your experience. We take feedback seriously and appreciate when former or current team members speak up. We use tracking tools to ensure accountability, protect client data, and maintain productivity standards in a fully remote environment. These tools are disclosed during the hiring process, and expectations are communicated clearly before employment begins. Regarding personal branding, no one is required to give up ownership of their private accounts. When we encourage team members to showcase their professional work, it is intended to support career growth and credibility in the ecommerce space, not to intrude on personal identity. We recognize that our performance standards and structure may not be the right fit for everyone. Our goal is to create a transparent, high-performance environment while continuously improving based on constructive input.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All