Fit in or get out... part II - Anonymous employee Smartsheet Employee Review

2.0
20 Dec 2022
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

[ Reposting as my previous review was deleted... ] Here's what the Pros were when I started years ago, but it's changing: Used to be the people, the culture, the money and the stock. Now, it's pretty much just the people. Not all teams are bad. Some still seem to have a decent thing going, so it depends on the team and level you are at. Sales has been tumultuous. Engineering seems brutal. Product is disorganized. Proceed with caution. Smartsheet can definitely be a great McLaren-style pit stop for your resume. Get in and get out quickly. Power-users love the product. Unlimited PTO

Cons

#1: The CTO: Toxicity has increased dramatically within Prod with the move to put the CTO in as CPO/EVP Engg (a move that utterly confounds every person I speak to). He'll fire people who disagree with him. I've seen it. "If you parrot back the things that he says, challenge him only so you can show backbone, but then swallow your pride and do what he says... you'll be fine." That was the advice someone was given! How does that show an appreciation of diverse thought? CTO has created a culture that is so bad, that most of the people who work under him have an average tenure of less than two years. Leads and manages like it's 2000. A mix of the worst of Microsoft and the worst of Amazon: Top-down, micromanager with an arrogant, "I could do your job" vibe. An uninspired "my way or the highway" leader who is trying to be Bezos but doesn't realize he's Ballmer. Mitigation: If you're in Engineering and you can maneuver yourself to be under the SVP of Engg, you could be safe. She seems like a decent human and has openly pushed back on him. She may be able to do this and get away with it because she's one of the few women (of color) in leadership. #2: Product. It's not great. There's constant talk about a product strategy, but it is veiled behind a curtain. When you say you don't know what it is, you get hammered for not knowing what it is. Things are mandated and we love "disagree and commit." But then people are blamed for doing what they were told to do if things don't work out. "You should have said something earlier!" I've also seen and heard of this happening far too often. Mitigation: If you are good at doing what you're told and executing it with excellence (i.e. don't ask too many questions, be prepared and positive about things changing constantly, excel at "disagree and commit"), you'll be fine. Get a couple of years here, use it as a stepping stone to something better. #3: Leadership. Used to be OK, despite the blatant cronyism. The culture is deteriorating on their watch right before their eyes and they blame people for not "being the change they want to see." Culture doesn't always have to happen top-down, but it feels like there's not only no responsibility for it, but no accountability for it either. Even things that are supposed to be "fun" for the staff are handled so sloppily. Case in point? Hack the Sheet. Sign-ups were low this year so our CTO threatened and belittled people for not participating. Classy. It is also getting harder and harder to ignore the fact that Leadership is beginning to protect themselves. They've become insular. With the recent economic downturn, the heat has been turned up and it is not looking pretty. The leadership has become ultra-defensive about their decisions and is not really listening. It's almost like they're just guessing and don't know what they're doing. The most recent example of this? Dennis Durkin. Beyond the glossing over of the serious allegations he’s facing, leadership was blind to the fact that this was going to look like cronyism/favoritsm. They underestimated the "appearance of shadiness" even if there was none. The latter exacerbated the former. Like Mentos dropped into a Coke bottle. All the communication around this was, "We've done our due diligence. Yes, people have told us that we could have done better. We need to do better, but stand by our decision nonetheless." It would have shown more backbone for Durkin to have been let go, but instead, we let the pressure build up until he resigned himself. Missed opportunity for leadership to act quickly and show that they listened to and valued the opinion of their staff. Mitigation: If you're good at ignoring the drama and chaos at the leadership level, if you don't want to get involved in matters of DEI, if culture doesn't matter to you too much, if you can generally just keep your head down... you can have a fine ride.

avatar
Smartsheet Response
3y
[Response to original post] Thank you for sharing your experience. At Smartsheet we’re building systems that scale beyond our current capabilities and that requires employees to challenge assumptions, learn new patterns, and innovate – all while balancing customer feedback. We have to constantly remind ourselves that we are barely scratching the surface of the opportunity Smartsheet has — so what got us this far will likely not get us to 10 or 100x of where we are today. I know that our work demands excellence and I’m focused on growing our team members who are meeting and exceeding expectations. With over 200 product enhancements launched in 2022 and more to come in 2023, we’re constantly adapting our approach to product innovation. This does mean operating our team differently, which is not easy. I’m grateful to our team members who have embraced the opportunity within these changes. Regarding leadership, our senior leaders have listened, learned, and grown a lot in the months since the appointment and resignation of our latest board member. I’m grateful that Smartsheet is a place where employees deeply care about our culture and feel comfortable expressing their opinions. In listening to employees like you, we are making improvements to our vetting process for future board leaders to incorporate more diverse perspectives from across the organization. Just one step we’re taking is to include our senior People & Culture leadership and our VP of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in board candidate reviews. If you’d like to share more about your experience I encourage you to reach out to people@smartsheet.com to share more. Thanks again for your feedback. – Praerit Garg, Chief Product Officer and EVP of Engineering

Explore other reviews about Smartsheet

5.0
11 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great collaborative environment and competitive

Cons

Easily overwhelmed with phone calls, chats, and emails.

avatar
Smartsheet Response
1w
We're so happy to hear that you're happy here! Collaboration with a healthy dose of competition is always great to hear, thank you for your review!
1.0
26 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Supportive of AI tooling. I had a great manager. I heard the severance packages are great, but I left of my own volition, so I don’t have personal experience.

Cons

Complete lack of direction or management at the mid to high levels of the company in product and engineering (most everyone left or was pushed out by cronyism from the private equity acquisition). No more equity offered to employees. No opportunities for promotion. They’ve shipped or are shipping most of the core products (including the core “sheet” aka Grid app) to India and have laid off tons of employees (somewhere between 12% and 15% of the company). Upper management did the thing where they had the US developers interview tons of people out of India, and then about half a year later laid off tons US developers, including several of the people that did the interviews. Upper management said that the India teams would be working on other projects, but clearly that was a lie. They laid off people without consulting their managers, or their manager’s managers, and without knowing what team they actually worked on or what they did. So entire teams were laid off unbeknownst to them. Very quick and poor handoffs to India, if any. You will likely be working on multiple teams at once, or moved to multiple teams during your time there in short periods of time. On-call can be a nightmare. There is no culture of any kind. Basically do not work here, whether you’re out of the US, India, or Bulgaria (the main countries for developers).

1
avatar
Smartsheet Response
3w
Thank you for your honesty. While we’re glad that you had a great team and the tools you needed, it’s incredibly tough to hear that other aspects of your experience were less than great. To your point about equity, we’d like to clarify that we do offer a limited equity pool with specific eligibility. That said, navigating transition is already tough, and adding in other aspects like global shifts and new leadership can make it feel even harder. We know the dust hasn’t completely settled, and we understand that we have a lot of work to do to repair employee trust and morale. We’ve set off on that journey, and we appreciate all of this feedback along the way. Thank you, and we wish you all the best in your next chapter.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All