employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

The Collier Companies

Is this your company?

The Collier Companies Reviews

3.0

51% would recommend to a friend

(226 total reviews)
avatar

Jennifer Clince

63% approve of CEO

52% positive business outlook

The Collier Companies has an employee rating of 3.0 out of 5 stars, based on 226 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The The Collier Companies employee rating is 20% below average for employers within the Real estate industry (3.8 stars).

Reviews by job title

226 reviews
1.0
25 June 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The 401k is decent but have to be there forever to be fully vested. The people who have been there forever are just like the company: stale, boring and never leaving Gainesville.

Cons

I truly thought I had joined a CULT once I started. It was scary. They have an acronym list a mile long, you are taught how you must only write an email in the subject line (which is the most inefficient process ever), you or vendors can’t use specific words, you must wear clothing with their ugly outdated logo, only read books they promote. The list goes on but truly like a communist society. After leaving, I felt like I had ptsd. So many things were not disclosed during the interview process. The turnover rate speaks volumes about the company. Nathan Collier isn’t a bad guy but the people he has running the show are incompetent and just comfy in their positions. It’s ironic they speak about constant improvement and not staying in the same place. Well, I have news for you: the only people who stay are never leaving Gainesville and would be hard-pressed to find employment elsewhere. The only employees that stay have been there forever and are never leaving because they would NEVER make it in another company. They spout 2x growth but it isn’t possible. Let’s see 12000 units in 50 years and trying to be on top 25 list of multifamily providers in the next 10 years. It isn’t going to happen! Operationally challenged company that is only focusing on development. I wouldn’t recommend this company to anybody.

avatar
The Collier Companies Response
4y
Thank you for your review. It is unfortunate you did not have the most positive experience as a Team Member. As an organization, we strive for “CANi” – Constant and Never-ending Improvements. We look forward to utilizing your feedback for the betterment of our team members and residents.
1.0
10 May 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Well, at least I know now what NOT to do as a property manager. I left a little stronger and a little wiser

Cons

If you have integrity, you will eventually get yourself in trouble. You will eventually feel like a car salesman, ripping off young people and making up excuses and lies for the upper managements lies and excuses to residents. Residents who are more or less fresh out of their parents house and often a long way from home. They don't know they are being scammed , basically ignored and mistreated because many of them have nothing to compare this first experience to. Parents are bamboozeled and conned as well. "fine print" leases and flat out lies. I can't tell you how many conversations I had with mothers and fathers worried to death for the welfare of their children, all the while knowing that (when the child does make it out of there) the plan is to hit them with astronomical damage charges that are falsely accused against the resident thereby holding the parent liable to pay or else turn them over to collections. That's just one example of the difficult and sometimes hopeless conversations I was having while, my instructions from the property manager was "don't even tell them who I am or they will never leave me alone" It's a cut throat environment within the company so you see a lot of jumping around for appearances and scrambling to make sure corporate doesn't see the real office environment. You quickly realize that when big brother isnt watching, doors will slam and management will take 3 hour lunches or even go on vacation without even notifying the office staff. I stayed and tried for the residents. I told them I would try to help them and I did. I was already getting in job offers from other companies and when I was discussing in interviews what I was personally going through, a couple employers already knew about collier companies reputation and warned me to keep a log of everything. And i am warning you now, Keep a log of everything if you feel like you're being harassed or if anything seems to be unfair or just wrong wrote it down and protect YOUR reputation. Try to make a liaison with corporate office. Regional managers are just senior cut throats so try to find someone at the big office that might be there to listen to you should you need them. No matter what, keep your integrity, treat the residents right they need someone on their side . The hugs and thank you so get even still around town are more rewarding than any paycheck ever was. I hope someone succeeds where I failed, I really mean that. Keep in mind that this company uses a reputation Internet software that alerts them when their "ratings" are low and will have anyone and everyone they can bribe to come onto (even this site) and write some "hotdogs and butterfly's" review to boost them back up. Notice how candid they sound? I am writing this all from my phone so forgive any errors I have made. It's not an easy story to have to tell.

1.0
6 Jan 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Lots of opportunities for training, but some of it is ridiculously benign (they're obsessed w/ the "7 habits..." ideology, though many leadership staff don't practice what they preach). Company is growing, but tends to hire HQ employees from external sources.

Cons

Ridiculous interview process, horrible internal communication, self-absorbed company... They basically force you to wear clothing emblazoned with their logo (an ugly/boring logo BTW) every day...it robs you of your individuality and opportunity to feel comfortable in your own clothing. // So many things get lost in translation because the internal communication between HQ employees really stinks. // Horrible marketing department. // The founder/owner, Nathan, acts like he's God gift to the community. His principles and ideas are all borrowed from elsewhere and not original...he does nothing innovative. It's also darn near impossible to get him to return an email or voicemail. Yet he is the public "face" of the company and gets a ton of undue credit. Yes, he busted his booty back in the day and built this really successful company, and he should get to enjoy the fruits of his labor and credit is due for the past success (but the current success nearly 100% goes to all the actual staff)...but, it's like he wants to work there but at the same time does not. It's like he perennially has one foot in and one foot out. // The CEO, Jennifer, is nice enough, but kind of dry and boring and not really the motivating or mentoring type. // The HR/talent department leaves a lot to be desired. It has gotten better over time, but their interview process is way too long and drawn out...they come across as indecisive by making candidates go through so many interviews and talk to so many different people and jump through all these hoops...all while not being transparent ahead of time that it will be a long process, nor keeping you up to date to let you know status updates or next steps. They literally will just ghost you for weeks at a time and then randomly pop back up and expect you to right away do another interview. // There is not a lot of diversity at the company, especially in management...it's mostly old white guys with the rest being old white women (just one BIPOC in management). // They also made us work in office during COVID quarantine...it's like they do not care about CDC guidelines of being indoors sharing the same airspace with so many other people. // Bottom line, all they care about is the "bottom line": Money.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 226 Reviews

Glassdoor has 231 The Collier Companies reviews submitted anonymously by The Collier Companies employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if The Collier Companies is right for you.