Awful management - Senior Auditor AIG Employee Review

1.0
17 May 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I learned a lot about the business working there, and my direct manager was great. I also had great coworkers whom I am still friends with

Cons

The internal audit department as a whole was completely dysfunctional when I was there. The head at the time said in team meetings more than once that all of the people who left the department for better opportunities were losers. I have news for her, almost all of the people who left have now gone on to much more successful jobs, no credit to her. She also made up reasons to give poor ratings, even when our own managers disagreed. They had a forced ratings distribution, and if you are new to the job or newly promoted, would give you a poor rating. That is really demotivating. When I brought proof of my performance, she didn't want to hear it. She was determined to give me a particular rating, and created a narrative to support it. My life was a living h3ll under her and when I tried to move internally and worked night and day to help them transition and document my work for an entire month, decided they wanted to keep me yet another month. I had to threaten to quit to be allowed to move on. And this is a person who made it very clear that she thought I was useless. Why try to keep me then? there was also a lack of trust on her part, and people weren't allowed to work from home or get certification if they didn't have a high rating. But it is impossible to break out of this box, if she has decided that you deserve a poor rating. She would also overturn my audit results, saying that it was more important to keep the client relationship. I agree, partnership with the business is very important, but that doesn't mean that we should just give a good rating if there's a weakness, does it? I will never forget the way she treated one of my hardest working coworkers, either. Turnover was really high, and I don't think that hard work will be appreciated there. Get your experience and move on.

Explore other reviews about AIG

5.0
11 June 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The 401(k) matching contribution is excellent.

Cons

Commuting to New York City four days per week. The schedule does not allow for remote work.

2.0
28 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Salary and vacation days are good but be careful you are not taking on multiple roles for this position.

Cons

If you’re considering applying, make sure to ask in the interview: Will there be someone else doing what I am doing? If not, the team is understaffed and all the responsibility will rest on your shoulders. Even with the vacation days, your days will be swamped and stressful. It is NOT worth it. Out of curiosity, I’ve been looking at their latest job postings for my department and there is so much packed into one role, it’s wild. You can tell the person they’re trying to replace clearly wore too many hats and it will be a long struggle to fill this position. Are my team members working in other time zones? You can face several early morning calls based on their hiring pattern. Some teams will require annual or quarterly traveling. Over the years, the company is hiring mainly white managers domestically in the USA, while lower roles are hired abroad or contractors. Meetings to accomodate offshore hours are brutal. What percentage of the day is in meetings? If you don’t have time to deliver on output because of meetings, you will likely have to stay late to complete the work. The company seems to hire very good talkers but not a lot of do-ers. Several meetings involved more people than needed. Managers seem to think “if I have to suffer through this meeting, everyone has to suffer”. If managers are fortunate enough to delegate the deliverables, they can handle some meetings by themselves. Who would be handling my onboarding and training when I start? If it is not your direct manager, your early success will be at the mercy of your peers who understandably are not responsible for onboarding you. Sadly, I have observed that the people-managers do not like to manage people. In fact, they value those that manage the manager and the team’s roadmap plan for them. The managers don’t seem to want to oversee the team or their deliverables. If there is a job change (salary, position, hours) how is that communicated? In my experience these things were not communicated or consented to. The change would apply in the system and you would have to conform accordingly.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All